Follow Us:

[Saintsfan1972]

i had to ga ahead and vote yes

[Platoon 86]

Yes, I say so.

[ollysj]

For me he is a bust w/o waiting after the upcomming season

[DoubleC]

I think so, too.

[Jimmy's Dignity]

I'm a huge Giants fan...and I think that this is really his make or break year, even with Sean Diehl as his left tackle. It took Peyton 3 years to really come into his own, hopefully Eli will pull it together and stop throwing off his backfoot every single damned time

[Sweets]

Welcome to GIF JD, hope to see you posting in the football forums as well this season.

I agree that this is his make or break year. He starts out great then peeters out in the second half of the season, which is weird.

[TJ]

So Eli...how's that trade working out for you so far? :mrgreen:

[Saintsfan1972]

Originally Posted by Jimmy's Dignity

I'm a huge Giants fan...and I think that this is really his make or break year, even with Sean Diehl as his left tackle. It took Peyton 3 years to really come into his own, hopefully Eli will pull it together and stop throwing off his backfoot every single damned time

thanks for your input dude, i was hoping to get some opinions from giants fans

[steadypimpin]

I never thought he was #1 material. He only got there because of his name. He would have been a low 2nd, high 3rd rounder if he wasnt a Manning. I think he's a bust.

[linz_renee]

I have to vote yes by default because I think he's already a bust... and a cry baby. He should change his name to Eli Puddin' Cup and call it a day.