Follow Us:

[Omen]

have at it my GIF brethren and sistern, who is/was the better QB. just place your vote and discuss amongst you selves. One a sb victor the other not

[Ridin Burgundy]

Doug Williams>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Dilfer>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Elisha> Marino

[K Train]

lol

[tigersucs]

Unless Manning can break some of the records of Marino and even his brother he will never be the QB that Marino was. Now if it were Peyton v Marino the vote goes to Peyton based on 1 SB win and even then it would be very close.

[ball in the baskett]

This cant be serious everyone said eli sucked before the playoffs this year. Eli is not a great QB. He was just on a team that was great the defensive line was beastly.

Hmm... Dan Marino held all the meaningful quarterback records at his time, and he came close to winning a Super Bowl. It's a toss up, but I just voted Dan Marino. :D

[86WARD]

Eli Manning.

[Jammin Jaguar]

You've got to be kidding me if you think this is even remotely up for debating.

Originally Posted by Jammin Jaguar

You've got to be kidding me if you think this is even remotely up for debating.

Because Eli won a championship. Marino didn't.

[SeanTaylor21]

Who the fuck voted for Eli.